Intellectual Frontiers

Ask Reviewers Whether Each Diagnostic Item Can Be Seen and Illustrated

Instrument 5: Practitioner Review of the Diagnostic

Use this to test the Child Experience Fragmentation Diagnostic with the people who would use it. For every item in the diagnostic, ask reviewers to answer the four questions below, say whether improvement in the item would plausibly matter to a child or family, and give an example.

Collect examples for every item. Items that practitioners cannot illustrate may be too abstract for a fieldbook.

  • Reviewer’s role:

  • Date:

Rate Each Item

Fill in one row per item. Answer yes, no, or unsure in the four test columns.

Item (number and cluster) Understandable? Observable? Meaningfully different from other items? Under the school’s control? Would improvement plausibly matter to a child or family? Example

Information 1

Information 2

Information 3

Information 4

Information 5

Instructional 1

Instructional 2

Instructional 3

Instructional 4

Instructional 5

Responsibility 1

Responsibility 2

Responsibility 3

Responsibility 4

Responsibility 5

Interpretive 1

Interpretive 2

Interpretive 3

Interpretive 4

Interpretive 5

Transition 1

Transition 2

Transition 3

Transition 4

Transition 5

Family 1

Family 2

Family 3

Family 4

Family 5

What Is Missing

Question Answer or notes

What important failure mode is missing from the diagnostic?